Skip to Content

Judgment on $3 Million Jury Verdict in Favor of Dearie Law Group Client Entered Against State of Washington for Failure to Report Child Sexual Abuse

Snohomish County Superior Court Judge Richard Okrent has entered judgment on a $3 million jury verdict awarded to Dearie Law Group client A.K., a victim of child sexual abuse, against the State of Washington, Department of Children, Youth, and Families (formerly DSHS).

The jury verdict was the result of a three-week trial in A.KvState of WashingtonDSHSet al., No. 19-2-01825-31, in which the State denied any responsibility for its employee’s failure to make a mandatory report.  Instead, the State claimed its employee had nothing to report and blamed the victim, necessitating a trial according to Raymond Dearie and Drew Lombardi of the Dearie Law Group, legal counsel for the victim, A.K.

“This tragic case comes down to a Child Protective Services employee’s failure to simply do her job,” said Dearie.  “Her whole job description revolved around the protection of children from abuse, but somehow the CPS Investigator forgot how to do her job.  If the CPS Investigator would have done the bare minimum, my client would not have been forced to endure years of abuse and emotional distress.”

A.K.’s legal counsel argued to the jury that the CPS Investigator had ample information requiring her to make a mandatory report alleging that A.K. was being sexually abused by former Monroe Police Department Sergeant Carlos Martinez.  The abusive relationship stemmed from events almost 20 years ago when A.K. was a student at Monroe Junior High School.

One week before the civil trial began, A.K.’s attorneys uncovered a tape-recorded interview of the CPS Investigator, who admitted that she was “one hundred percent sure something physically was going on between them.”  As Mr. Dearie explained, this was “a true smoking gun situation.”

The CPS Investigator never made a mandatory report, possibly due to a conflict of interest.  During the trial, multiple witnesses testified that they believed the CPS Investigator was having an affair with Martinez.

As a result of the failure to make a mandatory report, A.K. was abused by Martinez for approximately seven years.

Dearie and Lombardi added that they “thank the members of the jury for following the law and holding the State responsible for its systemic failure.”  They further added: “We hope this verdict will finally allow A.K. to move forward with her life and motivate the State to make systemic corrections to ensure that this never happens again.”

Additional News Coverage:

Everett Herald:

Published in Business Wire, November 14, 2023

View Article

Related Articles

Ray Dearie Awarded ABOTA Trial Lawyer of the Year

The American Board of Trial Advocates – Washington Chapter has named Ray Dearie Trial Lawyer of the Year for 2023.  Known as one of the highest honors a Washington trial lawyer can receive, Ray was awarded Trial Lawyer of the Year in recognition of his unparalleled advocacy on behalf of Dearie Law Group clients, his superb reputation for civility and ethics, and his distinguished career (including multiple multi-million dollar verdicts and settlements in 2023). 

Read More

Dearie Law Group Secures $21 Million Jury Verdict in TBI Case

On Thursday, August 24, 2023, a Pierce County jury returned a $21 million verdict in favor of Dearie Law Group client Cristina Anderson.  The jury’s verdict is in addition to an undisclosed seven-figure settlement with the City of Sumner that was reached prior to trial for alleged negligent roadway design.

Throughout the legal process, Raymond J. Dearie, Jr. and Drew V. Lombardi served as counsel to Cristina Anderson, a loving mother and former English as a Second Language Teacher.

Read More

Ray Dearie Earns #17 Verdict on Top Verdict’s Top 50 for 2022

Ray Dearie, Founding Attorney of the Dearie Law Group, earned the #17 verdict in 2022 per’s annual listing of the top 50 verdicts in Washington State.

Read More

DSHS to pay girls $8 million for sexual abuse in foster home

A jury awarded two teenage girls $8 million Wednesday, settling a lawsuit they filed in Whatcom County against the state Department of Social and Health Services after suffering years of sexual abuse in their foster home.

Read More